The Washington Times-Herald

Columns

January 25, 2014

Montana still the G.O.A.T.

It’s the time of year again. I don’t mean the lead up to the Super Bowl, but the time when we talk ourselves to death about Peyton Manning’s legacy. We simply can’t help it, but to compare Manning to fellow great quarterbacks Joe Montana, Dan Marino, Johnny Unitas and John Elway. The problem isn’t that we’re having this discussion, but the parameters to which we start and end this debate.

ESPN’s Dan Graziano wrote that Manning is the greatest quarterback of all time no matter what the result of next week’s Super Bowl is and I find that to be utterly hilarious. Manning will go down as one of the 10 best to ever play the most difficult position in all of sports, but to say the result of his third and possibly final appearance in the Super Bowl doesn’t matter is a little silly.

We first heard proclamations like these back in Jan. 2010 in the lead up to the Super Bowl in Miami, Fla. between Manning’s Indianapolis Colts and the New Orleans Saints. At that time after leading the Colts to a 14-0 start to the season and easy wins over the Ravens and Jets in the playoffs, Manning appeared to be on the verge of his second championship in four years. Just winning a second championship still seemed strange that anyone could elevate him over Montana, who was 4-0 in the Super Bowl and didn’t have commit a turnover in those games.

The coronation for Manning in South Florida was not meant to be as New Orleans quarterback Drew Brees dominated the Indianapolis secondary and Manning threw a soul crushing pick-6 with under four minutes to play to clinch the Saints’ first Super Bowl victory, 31-17. The loss would turn into the first of three straight playoff losses for Manning. Fast forward to Jan. 2014 and Peyton is back in the Super Bowl with a loaded offense and the narrative surrounding No. 18 is back.

Text Only
Columns
  • Learning from the examples of Jesus I was reminded again on Thursday night at our church's Maundy Thursday service about humility and obedience. As part of the traditional service, we not only take part in communion, but have a foot-washing service. On the evening before his death, Jes

    April 19, 2014

  • The past is prologue When I left Bankers Life Fieldhouse on Saturday, I watched a lot Barr-Reeve leave depressed and disappointed. The Vikings had lost a heartbreaking Class A final and I think a lot of people were wondering how and why. I'm not sure if either question n

    April 1, 2014

  • A Viking team to remember All roads lead to where you stand. And today, the Barr-Reeve basketball team will find themselves at center court of the Class A State Finals. Whether they win or lose is now irrelevant, as their legacy has already been written. This team will be rem

    March 29, 2014

  • Those hard working worms When the word "worm" comes up in conversations, there is often a wide range of ideas as to what people think about worms. Someone may think of a worm as a creepy, crawly thing that wiggles around in the earth, that young boys used to tease young gir

    March 25, 2014

  • Long live the Big East It first started when I was a student at Indiana University in Bloomington and I didn't quite understand. Most of my friends and people I would meet while watching college basketball wondering how on earth I couldn't be a crazed Hoosier fan, despite

    March 22, 2014

  • Twigs give Leatherwood its name One of our lesser known Indiana shrubs also has a rather unusual name. This is the leatherwood. A usually short shrub, it only grows to a height of around six feet, leatherwood receives its name from the soft leather-like twigs that extend out from t

    March 18, 2014

  • 'Old-school' sharing found in different ways The concept of sharing has taken on a new meaning since I was supposed to have learned it many years ago. What we all know, or supposed to be taught, was to let others take part in your good fortunes. When we all learned about sharing, it was over ou

    March 15, 2014

  • How far was Hooterville from Walton's Mountain? I have always said that television is the one item that binds my generation together (the generation that still watches televison, talks on phone and asks people for directions instead of using one device for all three). And with that in mind, it ma

    March 8, 2014

  • Time to seed the state tournament

    The Indiana boys basketball state tournament got underway Tuesday night as the most exciting month in high school began. As the old saying goes, "In 49 other states, it's just basketball, but this is Indiana." With that in mind, the IHSAA needs to to take a long look at seeding the state tournament.

    March 7, 2014

  • The pen is mightier than the sibling GD (Grand Dad) came to town for a visit recently and before he left I heard him ask Ava if she would to write something for his newspaper back home. She said she would but I could tell by the look on her face that she didn't really want to. She was p

    March 6, 2014