As Elijah was trying to start his pickup, Tammy came out of the house and slashed a tire on the truck. He told officers he got out of the truck and threw a brick at her to knock the knife out of her hand. At that point Ptl. Daniel Wilkins arrived on the scene and ordered the couple away from the knife, which he could see laying on the ground.
Tammy denied stabbing Elijah and told investigators he must’ve stabbed himself on the way out of the house. She said the blood spatter in the residence was from a bloody nose Elijah gave her.
Both Stolls were treated and released at Daviess Community Hospital. Elijah was transported home, and Tammy was transported to the Daviess County Security Center, where she was being held on $100,000 bond.