The Washington Times-Herald

Local Sports

January 25, 2014

Montana still the G.O.A.T.


Winning the Super Bowl shouldn’t be the end-all-be-all of any quarterback discussion, but you can’t just ignore that this is only Manning’s third trip and he’s won the big game just once. Montana, Brady and Elway have a combined 14 trips to the Super Bowl with nine victories. Some of this is luck and some of it has nothing to do with the quarterback’s production, but it’s inarguable that it is all part of the player’s resume if you are having a discussion like this.

There are several problems with having any discussion of a player’s legacy while he is still active, but my biggest with this one is that Manning’s greatest contemporary rival, Tom Brady, has arguably had the better career. Brady has a better touchdown-interception ratio, postseason record and more Super Bowl rings (3-1). Where a lot of the hyperbole gets started is the gawdy stats Peyton puts up during the regular season rival Brady, Brees or even Aaron Rodgers. Manning has 491 career touchdown passes and will likely own every quarterback record when he decides to retire. For example, if you just look at the stats, Manning was far better in the 2013 regular season than Brady, but of course perception is not always reality.

Manning led the No. 1 offense while handing the ball off to Knowshon Moreno and throwing 55 touchdowns and just 10 interceptions and nearly 5,500 yards to a receiving group that featured Demaryius Thomas, Eric Decker, Wes Welker and Julius Thomas. Brady had 25 touchdowns, 11 interceptions and another 4,000-yard season, but he had All-Pro tight end Rob Gronkowski for just seven games and his most reliable receiver was Julian Edelman, who wouldn’t even get on the field for Denver.

The facts are that for the entirety of their careers, Manning has had far more offensive firepower. Brady had only two full season of Randy Moss and in one of those seasons he led the Patriots to a 16-0 regular season. Brady has done far more with less offensive talent.

Text Only
Local Sports
  • SPT-WT-082114-ND TEAM PHOTO New look for the 2014 Cougars ELNORA — The North Daviess Cougar football team will have some big shoes to fill in 2014, and, none will be bigger than replacing the state’s leading rusher Colton Lengacher.However, in spite of Lengacher’s loss to graduation, most believe Coach Scot

    August 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • SPT-WT-082114-AMBER TAYLOR PIC WHS downs Pike Central, improves to 2-0 Another match and another win for the Washington volleyball team. The Hatchets (2-0) stayed undefeated by sweeping their opponent with ease. Washington dispatched Pike Central (25-16, 25-16, 25-15) just 24 hours after doing the same to Southridge.Was

    August 20, 2014 2 Photos

  • WC takes down Shoals 8-0 in season-opener SHOALS — On the opening night of the boys soccer season, Washington Catholic looked to be in mid-season form. The Cardinals defeated Shoals 8-0 behind hat trick’s from Blaine Fuhs and Ethan Wichman. “In the first half we played pretty well,” said Was

    August 20, 2014

  • Hatchets cruise to season-opening win A first impression is important in all walks of life, and sports is no different. Washington started the boys soccer season with a dominant performance against Princeton Tuesday night at the Sports Complex. The Hatchets’ 14-0 victory featured a swarm

    August 20, 2014

  • Hatchet preview pic Hatchets ready to rebuild The Washington Hatchets hope that in spite of small numbers, a new offense will help add some wins to the 2014 Hatchets.Washington went 1-9 last season, but added a win against North Knox and played well in the sectional against powerhouse Brownstown

    August 20, 2014 1 Photo

  • Sports Briefs Washington beats SullivanThe Washington boys tennis team started the season with a 5-0 win over Sullivan Monday night. Michael Ramsey (6-2, 6-1), Jacob Overton (6-2, 6-2) and Jayden Bailey (6-4, 6-2) were all victorious in the singles matches. Washin

    August 20, 2014

  • We all lose with the Paul George injury An athlete's time to perform at peak condition is so finite that we often take it for granted. The prime of any athlete's career can be so short that we often don't appreciate what we're seeing, because we assume it will continue for a long time. For

    August 18, 2014

  • Local sports schedule MONDAY 8/18 Tennis Barr-Reeve at Bedford North Lawrence 5 p.m. Edgewood at North Daviess 5 p.m. Sullivan at Washington 5 p.m. Volleyball Loogootee at Paoli 7:30 p.m. TUESDAY 8/19 Tennis Linton at Barr-Reeve 4:30 p.m. North Daviess at Wood Memorial 5

    August 18, 2014

  • Liz Horton Valpo Horton to play in Germany Liz Horton’s first two years on the hardwood for the Valparaiso Crusaders women’s hoops squad were mostly lost to injury. But now, after a successful senior season at Valpo, Horton will have the chance to get those lost seasons back and get paid alon

    August 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • SPT-WT-081614-ALEX RUIZ PIC Hatchets, Cardinals ready to get back on the field A year ago, both boys’ soccer teams in Washington played for a sectional championship, and as the 2014 begins, the Hatchets and Cardinals are ready to go. Washington begins another season looking to add to historic boys program, while Washington Cath

    August 16, 2014 2 Photos